top of page

You Don’t Have to Give Up What You Love to Find Love

Writer: Caity Wilkinson
Caity Wilkinson
Oct 25
6 min read

Hi darling,


There’s one flavor of advice that well-meaning women often give each other that I hate, and it goes something like: 


“When are you going to settle down, find a good man, and start a family? When are you going to stop living like this and get serious? You can’t be planning to do this forever.” 


As if having fun and exploring your personal interests are the antithesis to conventional success and stability in your life. Ha!


This expectation really pisses me off. It’s so outdated and dismissive of women’s ambitions beyond the culturally-prescribed expectation to make more people and take care of a man the second we become adults ourselves. 


It implies that a woman can only enjoy her freedom and her passions for so long before it’s time to give them up and become a caretaker… you know, by abandoning her own desires to cater to other people’s, as she’s been conditioned to do across most of her life anyway. And that’s before we bring in the whole ‘make a family and be heterosexual’ expectation. The idea that finding love means giving up your independence is exactly the kind of assumption we need to push back against.


I have a friend whose coworker loves to pester her with these types of “you can't have personal interests and a family (unless you're a man)” rhetorical propaganda questions. 


Without revealing specifics about her personal life, my friend has a hobby that she spends hours a day practicing. She’s truly exceptional at it, both personally and competitively. And while she wants to get married and have children someday, she’s built her current life around this activity as a daily priority outside of work. 


It’s central to her identity and a non-negotiable part of her everyday life. So she’s clear that any viable partnership must accommodate the time she needs to pursue it. Otherwise, that person simply isn’t the right partner for her. 


My friend and I agree that the expectation that she should give up her passion just because society says so is ridiculous, because a person dedicated to having both their passions and family can usually find a way to make that work if they really want to. But the tragedy is that so many women don’t seriously consider that possibility, so they give up parts of themselves because they think that’s the only way to have a partner and children in this lifetime. 


(Again, notice how society rarely demands the same “give up what you love” sacrifice from men.)


Every time my friend’s coworker brings this up, hoping my friend will reconsider her choices, it begs the question: why are we uncomfortable with a woman choosing herself? And what does that discomfort reveal about our own choices?


Here’s Why Another Woman Might Secretly Be Triggered By You Not Giving Up Your Independence


When we see another woman holding firm in areas where we’ve sacrificed, it can stir up some strong feelings. 


“That’s not fair! She doesn’t deserve that! She can’t do that! That should be me!” we jealously think, as we grind our teeth and try to pretend she’s the problem.


Here’s a fun life lesson: jealousy can point you toward something you want but haven’t allowed yourself to pursue. 


That realization can sting because part of us feels ashamed and unworthy for not already having the thing we want.


Maybe seeing her makes us realize we’ve fallen short of our dreams, and we feel trapped or hopeless about changing that. It's easier to criticize her for being “unrealistic” than to recognize the hidden pain within our own disappointment and regret.


Maybe we believed the lie that finding a partner and having children requires sacrificing substantial parts of who we are. And now that we see someone challenge that assumption, we realize our sacrifices weren't as necessary as we thought. (Ouch.)


This triggers a psychological defense mechanism: villainize the other person so we don't have to confront our own emotional pain. Or try to pressure her into making the same choices we did. (Misery loving company, after all.)


Sometimes, another woman's freedom reminds us of possibilities we haven't allowed ourselves to consider.


And when that happens, we have a choice. We can try to convince her that she’s wrong (don’t do this), OR we can get curious about what thoughts and feelings her choices spark for us (ding, ding!) and use that information to help us shape our life into what we actually want. 


There’s Less of a Rush to Settle Down Than You Think


Wanting a partner doesn’t mean you need to give up your independence and rush into a relationship with someone who isn’t right for you. 


There are billions of people on earth. Yes, it takes time to find one of your people and get to know each other. And if creating children with your own body is important to you, reproductive timelines can be a real consideration (reminder that surrogacy and adoption may also be worth considering, depending on your circumstances). But there's no need to sacrifice the things that make your life meaningful just to secure a partner. There are different ways to build a family. You get to decide what matters to you and what kind of future you want to pursue.


Woman hiking looks to her right and smiles. Text overlay reads: The right partner won't want you to give up your life for them.

And yes, building a family with someone requires adjustments and shared responsibility, because children need time and attention, and partners need to divide responsibilities and make decisions together. But there's a big difference between adjusting your life to accommodate additional priorities, and abandoning the things that make your life fun and meaningful because someone expects you to. Why pursue a partnership that requires you to give up the life you love, when you could look for someone who wants to build a life with you?


Borrowing my friend’s example, a compatible partner could help her protect her hobby time, while sharing family responsibilities with her and finding practical ways for him to pursue his own interests, too. 


By comparison, an incompatible partner might resent the time she spends on her hobby, treat her commitment to it as evidence that she isn't devoted enough to him, and expect her to conform to his lifestyle preferences (without him doing the same for her) simply because she's his wife.


The first partnership is a true partnership that makes room for both people, where she still gets to feel like herself. The second requires her to shrink herself for him (which no one should have to do, and which no partner should want if they truly love you). 


The Danger of Making a Relationship Your Finish Line


Partnership can be part of a fulfilling life without becoming the entire point of it.


Women are conditioned to treat partnership, especially marriage, as a defining event that makes the rest of her life fall into place. “First comes love, then comes marriage, then comes baby in a baby carriage,” the old song goes. 


But following a list of checkboxes rarely leads to personal fulfillment because it isn’t personal. It’s not customized to you, your wants, your ambitions, or your pleasures. It’s just what we’re all told to do… often long before we figure out whether it’s what we actually want. 


Making partnership the finish line creates a huge problem because your life becomes defined by the role you're playing in someone else's life instead of the life you're building for yourself. You stop pursuing interests that don't fit neatly into the family's plans. You stop imagining possibilities that might inconvenience the people who depend on you. You gradually lose touch with the person you were before you became so focused on being a good partner or parent. And if you're like my friend's coworker, you might eventually feel resentful toward women who haven't made the same sacrifices.


Relationships and children can bring enormous love, meaning, and fulfillment into your life. But creating and loving your family doesn't mean you have to stop being a person with your own interests, ambitions, and desires.


You Just Need to Know What You Want


There’s an Eartha Kitt interview I love (her laughter gives me life!) where she pushes back against the interviewer’s suggestion that she should compromise her standards or lifestyle in exchange for a relationship with a man. 


Her refusal to erode herself for a relationship highlights an essential truth: while healthy relationships require some negotiation, giving up what matters to you simply to preserve your partnered status isn’t virtuous; it’s self-abandonment driven by fear of being abandoned by that partner.


If you are repeatedly sacrificing the things that make you feel alive so that someone else can have the life or relationship they want, it’s worth asking yourself what you are actually building together. 


Are you both making room for each other? Are your priorities taken seriously? Can you pursue what matters to you without defending its importance every time? Or have you just learned that the easiest way to keep the peace is to stop asking for what you want? Is the life you’re building one you actually want, or just one that looks right to other people?


You don’t have to convince anyone that your priorities make sense. You just need to decide what those priorities are for yourself and be willing to take them seriously when deciding whom to build a life with.


And if another woman feels uncomfortable with your refusal to settle, that’s hers to work through.


Passionately, Caity


P.S. If you're ready to reconnect with what you actually want in love and life, take a look around my shop for resources to help you stop self-abandoning and start making room for yourself again.


[Psst - Enjoying what you’re reading? Click here to subscribe to my email list so you never miss a post!]

bottom of page