top of page

Can an Emotionally Unavailable Man Change? Not Because You Love Him

Writer: Caity Wilkinson
Caity Wilkinson
Nov 9
7 min read

Hi darling,


Ever met a man with so much potential that only you could see? And you just knew if you could shower him with love and build total emotional safety between the two of you, he’d blossom into the perfect, devoted partner you envisioned all along, and you’d sail off into the sunset together?


Me either. 


Just kidding. I spent the last two decades chasing the “broken” guys. The projects. The “nobody understands me” brooding poetic type. 


(A chase pattern which I now realize had infinitely more to do with my own inner wounding than theirs. But anyway…)


Now that I’m old and learned, I want to share this message with anyone who needs to hear it today. Especially those of us who date and dump partner with cis-men. 


And to be honest, I'm writing it to myself as much as I am to you. Consider this a dose of much-needed ‘tough love’ to the both of us.


Because somewhere in our youth, we were both fed this idea that emotionally unavailable men are these tough, feral manimals brimming with potential, who just need the right woman to inspire them to become into the romantic, devoted partners we know they can be. 


You see the vision. He’s tender when he lets his guard down. He can connect when he feels safe. These are the seeds of what you know will come. And if you’re patient enough, understanding enough, and communicate in exactly the ways he needs (because he’s so sensitive and fragile and traumatized, and you’re so empathetic and understanding)... then he’ll finally step up to meet you. You just need to hold out long enough. 


And being the stubborn overachiever you are, that’s no problem! You think: “Watch me make this work. If anyone can do it, it’s me. I’ve earned it. He’s going to wake up one day and realize I’ve always been the one.”


Plus, imagine the power thrill of someone who can make another person feel whole just by (patiently) loving the shit out of them. Yum. And the validation and egoic thrill of being the one who did it. The one who got through after he pushed everyone else away. The special one. His chosen one! 


Imagine the bond that would create. The deepest connection either of us has ever felt... It's so close. He just has to realize it, say yes, and let those walls down for me! It's kind of romantic, in a creepy, twisted way.


Except that life and romance don't actually happen like that, most of the time. And certainly not in healthy couples. 


Woman looks sad in thought, resting on couch, head on her hand. Text overlay reads: Loving him isn't enough to make the relationship work.

So Can an Emotionally Unavailable Man Change?


Of course; anyone can. Especially with a good therapist. 


But – and here’s the important part – not before he genuinely wants to. 


What sucks is that your love, no matter how passionate, cannot do that part for him. He has to do his own homework.


Ugh. So how will I know when he genuinely wants to? Easy: when he starts taking action to make real changes happen. And maintains that action, persistently. 


You can all but ignore his words here, because it’s the action that actually means something. And it’s that lack of his action that probably led you here to read this today.


Speaking of ignoring words…


  • His “maybe someday” passive deflections don't count. He’s not seriously considering what you’re asking in that moment; he’s just saying that to get you to stop talking about it. 

  • Heartfelt things he says in the moment but doesn’t follow through on also don’t count. Even if he truly means them in the moment, if he doesn’t act on them, they’re an empty vocal gesture. 


An emotionally unavailable man is a traumatized man. He’s learned to become guarded, to detach, to escape, to distance himself from the kinds of vulnerability that a real relationship requires, as a defense mechanism to protect him from re-experiencing what created a specific emotional pain for him in the past. And unless he’s chosen on his own to learn how to safely connect with you (or anyone else) at depth, it's not going to happen. 


What makes this extra frustrating is when you can see with painfully obvious clarity that it’s just fear holding him back, and if he’d only take those baby steps toward you, he’d see how safe you’ve made it for him, and everything would be fine. 


Unfortunately, his capacity to become a great partner is not the same as his willingness to become one.


Gif from The Simpsons, Bart looks at man twisted in a complicated acrobatic position and says "I can do that, but I don't want to."

Swimming analogy: You can throw as many life preservers as you want at someone, maybe even suit them up with a life vest and a dozen kids’ floaty wings, and pinky promise that the water is only four-and-a-half feet deep. But until they are genuinely ready to learn how to swim, they're not going to jump in that water with you.


So why doesn’t he want to change yet? I’m going to let you in on a little secret here: he probably likes things exactly as they are now. It’s working fine for him! Otherwise, he would be changing. 


How did he get that comfortable? That’s the ironic part… you probably made it that way for him by doing all of the emotional labor, always going above and beyond. (Because, you know, you were investing in him.) Your love is a cozy blanket that lets him stay exactly where he is without feeling the consequences of his own maturity stagnation. Womp, womp.


The other important part here: Whether the relationship has always been one-sided or just more recently, it’s not healthy for you to stick around waiting for him to change his mind. 


Walking away is rarely easy… but it may be time to seriously consider it.


The "Good Woman" Complex is a Trap and a Lie


As a woman, it’s easy to feel like a failure when a man you want doesn't open his heart to you…  especially when you did everything you thought you were ‘supposed’ to do to earn his commitment.


He enjoyed spending time with you. You were his top confidant, the one he told his deepest secrets to. You were an expert emotional comfort person for him. And he was very attracted to you. Your bedroom time was fucking electric. So what the hell was missing???


That’s the trap, and it catches us at every stage of dating and partnership. You can be human perfection, and still not be ‘the one’ for him, or not enough to inspire him to want to change. 


You treated his emotional immaturity like a test you were uniquely qualified to ace, by studying and strategizing and softening and adjusting and trying again, for years. And you probably blamed yourself whenever you didn’t get the result you wanted – because blaming yourself lets you pretend that you had some control over the outcome, and because it’s hard to admit that no, he’s just a guarded communicator who isn’t giving you enough. 


That’s a compatibility problem, not a ‘you’ problem. The only ‘you’ problem here is that you haven’t left the relationship yet.


What If He Is Trying To Change?


This one’s gotten me before: when he’s trying… sort of. 


Maybe he’s even doing his best. It isn’t enough yet, but baby steps are giving you hope that your vision for his success is still possible. (Damn that hope.)


Baby steps are a good start, because you and I know that real growth is slow and uncomfortable. But they’re not everything. He also needs to name the problem, accept responsibility for it, keep taking concrete steps, and keep following through over time. 


There needs to be obvious, sustained progress forward. Promises or glimpses of potential don’t count. Neither does one great week after you threaten to leave him, if it’s followed by three weeks of regression.


And regardless, his effort does not obligate you to wait around for him. You can appreciate his progress without putting your life on hold until he catches up. 


You shouldn’t have to drag him toward every milestone, either. Stop trying to do his work for him! His growth shouldn’t feel like pulling teeth (for you). 


At best, your love can inspire him as living proof of what’s possible. But you can’t take responsibility for his growth (or lack), and you can’t want it badly enough for both of you to make it happen on its own.


Here’s What To Ask Yourself If You Feel Stuck:


  • Am I already getting the relationship I want, or waiting for it to show up?

  • Is he working on the problems affecting our relationship? What changes am I seeing? Or am I just holding onto promises?

  • Is he doing at least as much emotional labor as I am, or am I still doing most of it?

  • If nothing changed, would I want this relationship exactly as it is?

  • Would I want my child to have a partner like this someday? 

  • If I was just meeting him for the first time tomorrow, would I start a relationship with him?

  • Which of my emotional needs are being neglected in this relationship? Why am I continuing to allow myself to be abandoned in that way?


You can’t control whether or when he changes, but you absolutely control what you’re willing to participate in. 


Say what you need, set your boundaries, and decide whether to stay or go. (He doesn’t need to agree.) 


You can love him completely and still know deep in your heart that he doesn’t have the emotional tools, capacity, or desire to build the relationship that you want together. 


Leaving lets you put your heart, transparency, vulnerability, and effort where they’re matched… no matter how much it hurts to actually rip the bandage off and leave.


With love (and no more crushes on my to-fix list), Caity


P.S. If you’ve spent years abandoning yourself trying to keep a connection alive, it’s time to stop dumping your energy where it’s not reciprocated. Take a look around my shop for resources designed to help you stop over-functioning in love, create new boundaries that feel good to you, and start investing your beautiful, loving energy into yourself (instead of everyone else).


[Psst - Enjoying what you’re reading? Click here to subscribe to my email list so you never miss a post!]

Comments


bottom of page