top of page

His "Sex First, Feelings Later" Line is Coercive Bullshit. Let’s Break Down Why.

Writer: Caity Wilkinson
Caity Wilkinson
6 days ago
6 min read

Hi darling,


Ever had a man you were dating tell you, usually early on in the getting-to-know-each-other process, "I need to have sex with a woman before I can open up to her emotionally"?


If you’ve been on the receiving end of this statement, and had mixed feelings about it, that’s valid. 


If it pissed you off, that’s valid, too. 


It sounds vulnerable, almost like a confession. But for some reason it makes your stomach feel uneasy… 


That’s your body telling you, “Girl, RUN!” before your brain has figured out why. And, as usual, your body is right. 


The ‘sex first, feelings later’ line is coercive bullshit that completely misunderstands (or disregards) the cis-female body’s arousal process and pleasure mechanisms.


Let’s dive into what’s actually going on here, because there are a few things at play under the surface of his words.


Emotional Pressure Shuts Down Your Pleasure


First, let’s look at the timeline. 


You’ve known each other for, what, a few weeks? How are you supposed to feel emotionally, mentally, and physically safe with someone you basically just met?


…much less someone who just told you that his inner world is on lockdown from you until after you grant him access inside the most vulnerable parts of your body? 


That’s insane. And unreasonable. And a TON of pressure.


And that’s not even considering the part about your physical pleasure. Looking at just the physical safety risks alone, we’re talking: pregnancy, disease, infection, injury, trauma,  death… 


That’s no small request from him.


To put it in perspective, can you imagine if I told the next guy who asked me out that I would consider saying yes to dinner with him, but only AFTER he gave me 4 of his teeth? 


“Yes, I’ll have 1 front, 1 canine, and 2 molars, all on the right side, please!” 


It’s that same level of audacity and absurdity. (Aubsurdity? Abdacity?) 


Meanwhile, Mr. Abdacity is treating his request like the most routine, logical restaurant order in the world. 


“I’m just telling you what I need. It’s my boundary.” 


Spongebob "I need" meme gif

Ughhhhhhhh.


Among other offenses, his request is ass-backwards when it comes to cis-female sexual biology. 


Our bodies require a baseline of emotional and mental safety and trust before we can start to relax enough to want and enjoy sex with someone. Especially with a new partner who we’re just getting to know intimately. 


I cannot stress this enough: A deep feeling of safety in our body is vital to our arousal process. 


So when a man creates a ‘let me touch your body, or we’re done’ ultimatum, he is putting immense pressure on you, the kind of pressure that causes your body to tense up (in a bad way). Now you feel unsafe, and your body is on-edge monitoring for danger. That kills intimacy, because vigilance prevents the kind of relaxation that your brain and body need for you to fully arouse and access much pleasure. It reroutes your focus from the lovely sensations you could be feeling (if you felt safe enough) into unsexy hyper-awareness of your surroundings. (Booooo.)


So if you’re clocking that this man is demanding a certain response from you while he simultaneously creates an environment that inhibits exactly that response? Yep, that is what’s happening. 


Ew, bad dog, no biscuit.


Emperor's New Groove "no touchy" meme gif
(me right now)

Why His Emotional Block is a "Him" Problem


“But Caity, you’re being way too harsh. Why do we assume this is manipulation? Can we give him the benefit of the doubt? Maybe he just needs to feel desired before he feels safe sharing his inner world. Maybe the only way he knows how to feel desired is through sex.” 


Let’s explore this idea. Maybe, in his mind, he really does think it’s not safe to talk about his feelings until after you’ve gotten naked together, because that’s how he feels most attractive and valued. Maybe, like many men, he learned that sex is the only place he’s allowed to be soft.


Okay, but… why should that be your problem? Even if that is all true for him, that still doesn’t require you to sacrifice your own boundaries to meet his request. 


If he truly cannot feel safe without sex, and you don’t want sex before you feel safe, you both are incompatible as partners together. And unless he wants to dive into that block in therapy on his own, this is a great time to part ways. 


If a grown ass man is so emotionally stunted that he cannot connect with another human being without getting under their clothes, that’s a deeply ingrained personal block that isn’t fair to take out on anyone else. That belongs in many long conversations with his therapist, not your body.


Again, look at what he’s asking for. He’s asking you to provide him sex now, risk your physical safety now, risk deep emotional entanglement on your side now… in exchange for maaaaaaaybe possibly one day kind of getting his emotional availability in the future. 


What kind of trade is that? You’re essentially prepaying, with your body and your mental + physical + emotional health, for something that may never arrive, and simply floating on the hopes that it does. 


Call it gambling. You might as well be dating a slot machine.


No thank you. 


Emotionally Closed-Off Sex is Terrible Sex for Women


If he is completely incapable of being emotionally open before sex, what makes you think he’ll suddenly be open during it?


Spoiler: He won't. 


Sure, he’ll be physically there. But emotionally? His mind will be somewhere else completely. That’s what happens when a person is emotionally guarded. 


You can feel that difference in your body when your partner feels “off” and the intimacy has a mechanical “get this over with” task vibe. You probably know exactly the feeling I’m talking about.


If you’re like me, emotional connection is what makes good sex feel GREAT, above and beyond what any physical technique can provide. 


– Sidenote: for men afraid of being replaced by toys, listen… I love my toys, but I’ve never connected with a toy like I have with a man before. That connection is the one thing a toy can never replace. So practice connecting emotionally, and your partner will have suchhhh a hard time wanting to take her/their hands off you. – 


But anyway… 


Text reads: Why would I want intimacy that doesn't leave me feeling absolutely treasured and adored???

Sex without connection isn’t worth it for me, because why would I want sex that doesn’t leave me feeling absolutely treasured and adored??? 


No one wants to be laying there next to someone, realizing you feel more alone now than you did an hour ago.


I want you emotionally and physically satisfied at your deepest core, even with a brand new partner. To accept less than that feels vacant and shallow – not the delicious, warm, exquisite, rich experience that sex is supposed to be. 


You’re not a blow-up doll or an old sock. You’re not disposable. You’re a human-fucking-being, and he needs to be respecting you as such.


And Then There’s The Friendship Double Standard


If he’s “incapable” (allegedly) of trusting someone without first getting naked and touching them, wouldn’t that mean he’s slept with every single one of his friends? 


No shame to folks who actually have slept with all of their friends, genuinely. I just doubt this man falls into this category.


This one’s easy to derail. If he has any buddies he relies on, trusts, has built a deep loyalty to, shares emotional stories with, etc., but has never shared body fluids with, he’s full of shit. That’s proof right there he knows how to build a bond the typical way, through time and consistently showing up in the relationship, but is choosing to coerce you into sex instead under the lie of “this is how I bond.”


“Oh, but those are male friends. It’s different when it’s with a woman.” 


Why, Greg? You’re admitting that you don’t know how to be friends with women, and you only see us as sex appliances? 


Yup. This is him telling you that he wants the sex part of the relationship to come before the trust part. And he feels perfectly fine using a sneaky shit script to try to fast-track it.


You Are a Partner, Not a Practice Ground


So, does he actually need sex to open up emotionally for you?


Maybe yes. Maybe no. But, honestly, the truth doesn’t matter, because the important part is that’s not going to work for you and the experience you want to have in love.


Never let somebody convince you that your need for emotional safety prevents them from being able to share their feelings with you. If a person wants you to compromise your boundaries (including your timeline) before they will consider sharing what’s going on in their inner world, that person does not have your best interests at heart and does not have the emotional skill set to be in a safe relationship with you. Or is lying to get in your pants without commitment.


Bianca Del Rio Drag Race meme reading, "Not today, Satan!"

RUN.


Openly, Caity


P.S. Ready to stop sacrificing your boundaries and start building a love life centered around your pleasure? Head over to caitycoaches.com/shop to grab my free worksheets, quizzes, and more!


[Psst - Enjoying what you’re reading? Click here to subscribe to my email list so you never miss a post!]

Comments


bottom of page